With housing measures making headlines this election season, rent caps are back on ballots in a number of markets. Ron Kutas, CEO of OneWall Communities, speaks to this strictly from the operator’s seat, on consequences rather than politics, and his description of what changes the day a cap passes is specific.
“First off, all discretionary spending stops,” he says. “The roof that was scheduled to be replaced this year is no longer getting replaced, and you best believe the operator is trying to see how long they can patch it instead. Renovations stop. But the most important thing that stops is supply in that market, because you can’t make the math work.” Reinvestment is the first casualty, and over time the asset itself deteriorates.
Kutas is careful to separate the individual from the policy. “If you’re the renter and you know you’re not getting an increase above 3 or 5 percent, it brings predictability, and it probably lowers your rent. For you as an individual, it’s awesome.”
As public policy, he argues, the effect inverts: “The biggest indicator of housing cost is supply. The more supply there is, the lower rents go. Constrain supply and rents go up.” His conclusion is that caps can end up hurting the very renters they intend to protect, while aging stock slowly falls out of service.
He does see a smarter version. Some ballots pair caps with housing bonds and zoning reform, and that, he says, “points to a legislative body starting to understand what actually moves the market.”
If he had to operate under rent control, two things would make it workable: a documented way to pass through real expense increases, such as a jump in property taxes, and an exemption for new construction.
For capital deciding where to deploy, regulatory direction is now a primary screen. “If it’s not a factor, that’s very unsophisticated capital,” Kutas says, pointing to markets where transaction volume has effectively frozen. For a workforce housing owner-operator, reading that landscape is part of the job.
Property management is complex, and the best solutions come from shared incentives. Whether you’re exploring new approaches or facing specific challenges, we’re here to talk.
Visit us at onewallcommunities.com or call us at (646) 596-7068.